is a never ending story

Democracy ‘on trial’ as Hong Kong 47 put together to face courtroom | Politics Information

Democracy ‘on trial’ as Hong Kong 47 put together to face courtroom | Politics Information

Table of Contents

Hong Kong’s largest nationwide safety trial will get underneath manner on Monday, with 47 pro-democracy activists and politicians standing trial for “conspiring to commit subversion” by organising an unofficial poll of the general public in 2020, days after a sweeping new safety legislation had been imposed.

Sixteen individuals are anticipated to plead not responsible, though that quantity may change by Monday as defendants weigh their choices in relation to the potential sentences they could obtain.

These charged embrace outstanding activists “Lengthy Hair” Leung Kwok-hung and Gordon Ng Ching-hang, who faces potential life imprisonment as considered one of 5 folks accused of being a “main organiser” of a ballot conceived as a manner for the democratic camp to decide on their strongest candidates for a Legislative Council election that was later postponed.

Defendants who plead responsible shall be sentenced after the trial has concluded and embrace internationally-known activists like Joshua Wong, who has already been convicted on different prices, and Claudia Mo, a former journalist turned legislator. Collectively, the 47 account for a lot of what stays of Hong Kong’s pro-democracy management after mass protests calling for political reform in 2019 got here to an inconclusive finish with the arrival of COVID-19, and the nationwide safety legislation pushed many into exile.

Unofficially on trial is the way forward for Hong Kong’s democracy motion, mentioned Eric Lai, a non-resident fellow at Georgetown Middle for Asian Regulation, as “pro-democracy actions and collaborating within the legislature” might be seen as threats to nationwide safety sooner or later.

“Nearly all of public opinion within the metropolis, the pro-democracy camp, has obtained greater than 50 p.c of the vote within the earlier decade’s elections and now the federal government selected to arrest and criminalise all the key leaders in Hong Kong,” Lai informed Al Jazeera.

“In a manner, it’s a trial for these leaders but in addition for his or her helps.”

Former lawmaker Helena Wong Pik-wan appears outside court after a prosecution appeal against her being given bail was rejected. She's wearing a lime green t-shirt and has her hands clasped together in thanks. She is accompanied by another woman. Media are around her.
Just a few of the 47 arrested have secured bail, together with former legislator Helena Wong Pik-wan. The prosecutor’s attraction in opposition to the choice was rejected [File: Lam Yik/Reuters]

Below the safety legislation, which took impact on June 30, 2020, the defendants resist three years in jail for conspiracy to commit subversive actions, between three and 10 years imprisonment for “lively participation” within the conspiracy, and between 10 years and life imprisonment if they’re deemed “principal offenders”.

The latter cost applies solely to Ng and 4 different defendants: former college professor Benny Tai,  former legislator Au Nok-hin, and former district councillors Andrew Hiu Ka-yin and Chung Kam-lun.

Tai and Au face among the most severe prices, in keeping with courtroom paperwork, for his or her “clear try to subvert the State energy, paralyse the operation of the [Hong Kong] Authorities”, in keeping with prosecutors. Prosecutors additionally allege the defendants hoped a crackdown on their actions would garner worldwide assist and result in the imposition of sanctions on Hong Kong and Chinese language officers.

Media ban

Held in July 2020, the vote was supposed as an unofficial “major” for pro-democracy candidates working within the deliberate September 2020 Legislative Council election.

Candidates hoped to safe a victory for the democracy camp and use the electoral majority to result in democratic change in Hong Kong.

Among the platform echoed calls for from the town’s mass protests in 2014 and 2019, together with the resignation of then-Chief Govt Carrie Lam, an unbiased inquiry into allegations of police brutality in the course of the protests and political reform with the intention of introducing common suffrage for the territory.

Below Hong Kong’s present political system, its chief is chosen by a bunch of individuals chosen by Beijing and solely a portion of its legislative seats are determined by the favored vote.

The July 2020 election drew greater than 600,000 voters, lots of whom waited in line for hours to participate, however the outcomes have been de facto voided when the federal government introduced the legislative election can be delayed for a 12 months resulting from COVID-19.

Following the ballot, as Hong Kong locked down, police swooped on the 47 defendants and 6 different people in a daybreak round-up of a sort sometimes reserved for organised crime teams.

The overwhelming majority of the 47 have been stored in jail since their arrest in January 2021, with bail granted to simply 13 folks. As a result of strict COVID-19 laws, detained activists have been unable to see their households and legal professionals, or obtain mail, for months.

Some defendants have reportedly been unable to entry Statements of Details detailing the costs levelled in opposition to them, so their legal professionals have been compelled to proceed blindly by the authorized system. The case was topic to a media ban that was solely lifted in August final 12 months.

William Nee, a researcher and advocacy coordinator at Chinese language Human Rights Defenders, likens the trial to a “pre-emptive strike” in opposition to a complete era of democracy activists and former legislators who vary in age from 24 to 66.

“The fees are completely absurd from a global legislation standpoint. Folks have the appropriate to run for workplace. As soon as elected, they’ve the appropriate to vote how they need. Clearly, Beijing is saying the mere truth you may wish to run and solid votes that go in opposition to our needs is a conspiracy to commit subversion is completely in opposition to worldwide legal guidelines and requirements,” Nee mentioned.

“That’s what’s in some ways so egregious about this case. It’s a unadorned assault on democracy in Hong Kong.”


Below Hong Kong’s frequent legislation system, legal defendants can sometimes obtain a discount of their sentence of as a lot as 25 p.c for pleading responsible on the primary day of trial, however this doesn’t apply to nationwide safety trials. Neither does the jury system, with this trial to be heard by a panel of three judges hand-picked by the town’s chief government.

A line of police on the street as a prison van arrives for a pre-trial hearing in relation to the case of the 47
The trial is predicted to final about 90 days with some defendants going through a life time period for alleged ‘subversion’ [File: Isaac Lawrence/AFP]

Maya Wang, a senior China researcher at Human Rights Watch describes the nationwide safety system as a “Frankenstein” parallel system carved into Hong Kong’s as soon as revered authorized system.

The trial is predicted to final about 90 days. It’s potential that on the finish of it, the accused will obtain a reprieve of “time served” for his or her pre-trial detention however most face a minimal sentence of three years imprisonment.

“All the things goes to be fairly unpredictable as we go alongside. I feel what is kind of clear is that Beijing is utilizing pretty elaborate legalese to dismantle Hong Kong’s pro-democracy motion,” Wang informed Al Jazeera.

“Seeing them on trial and being detained is such a cognitive dissonance for thus many individuals in Hong Kong. It truly is a visible illustration of repression.”